Websites
Your own online shop or a marketplace listing?
Selling on eBay, Amazon or Etsy versus running your own online shop. What each gives you, what each costs you, and a simple way to choose.
A marketplace listing gets you in front of shoppers who are already there, with very little setup. Your own online shop gets you control: your brand, your prices, your customer list and your rules. Most small Australian retailers do better treating them as two jobs, not a contest. The marketplace finds new buyers; your shop is where the relationship, and the repeat sales, live.
What a marketplace gives you
Marketplaces such as eBay, Amazon and Etsy have an audience before you arrive. You list a product, set a price and the platform handles the storefront, search and checkout.
- Fast start. You can list your first product in an afternoon, with no website to build.
- Built-in traffic. Shoppers searching on the marketplace may find you without ever hearing your name.
- A familiar checkout. Buyers already trust the payment flow, which helps when nobody knows your brand yet.
That makes a marketplace a sensible way to test whether a product sells at all, before you invest in anything bigger.
What a marketplace takes in return
The trade-off is control, and it shows up in four places.
- Fees. Marketplace costs usually come in several kinds: a listing fee, a percentage of each sale, a payment processing fee, and often paid promotion to be seen. Every platform sets its own and changes them, so read the current fee page of the one you use and work out your margin on a real product before you commit.
- Competition on the same page. Your listing sits next to similar products, often with a lower price one scroll away. Shoppers compare on price because that is what the page invites.
- Someone else's customer. The platform decides what you can send buyers and how you can contact them. You may not be able to add a buyer to your own email list, and the shopper often remembers the marketplace, not you.
- Someone else's rules. Listing policies, search ranking, account reviews and fees can change, and a suspended account can stop your sales overnight.
None of that makes marketplaces a bad idea. It means you are renting shelf space, and you should know what the rent covers.
What your own online shop gives you
An online shop on your own domain is the opposite trade: slower to start, more yours.
- Your brand and your page. No competitor's product appears beside yours, and you decide the photos, the wording and the story.
- Your customer list. With permission, you can follow up, announce new stock and sell again without paying a platform each time. See who owns your domain and hosting for why the account details matter.
- Your pricing and policies. Bundles, shipping rules, gift cards and pre-orders are your call.
- A place Google can send people. People searching for your shop's name, or for a product you make, can land on your own pages. How your business appears in search is covered in Google Business Profile or website.
The cost of that control is that traffic is not included. Nobody arrives just because the shop exists, so you need a way to bring people: search, Instagram, email, word of mouth, your physical store or market stall.
Side by side
| Marketplace listing | Your own online shop | |
|---|---|---|
| Time to first sale | Days | Weeks, plus the time to bring visitors |
| Where buyers come from | The platform's own shoppers | Your search, social, email and local reach |
| Who owns the customer | Mostly the platform | You |
| Brand presence | Limited to your listing | Whole site, your look |
| Main costs | Fees on each sale and paid promotion | Build, hosting and your own marketing |
| Risk | Rules and fees you do not control | You must earn the traffic |
| Best for | Testing products, reaching new buyers | Repeat customers and a brand you want to grow |
What it costs with Realtiq
Prices in Australian dollars. Every proposal is confirmed in writing before we start.
A Realtiq online shop is built on your own domain, which you own. Prices are in Australian dollars, and the websites and online shops service page has the details. If you already sell in a store, the retail shops page shows how a shop fits next to it.
A simple way to combine them
Most small shops do not need to choose forever. A sequence that works for many:
- Test on a marketplace. List a few products and see which ones sell and at what price.
- Build your shop around the winners. Put the best sellers on your own site with good photos and clear delivery details. The pages a small business website needs is a handy checklist.
- Point people to your shop. Use packaging, your Instagram profile, a business card or a market stall, within each platform's rules, so repeat buyers come to you.
- Keep the marketplace as a shopfront, not the business. If its fees or rules change, your own shop is still there.
Before you sell anywhere
- Australian Consumer Law applies to what you sell online, whichever channel you use. The ACCC publishes guidance for businesses on refunds, product descriptions and pricing; read it before you write your policies.
- Tax rules apply too. If you are unsure whether you need to register for GST, check the Australian Taxation Office guidance or ask your accountant.
- Photos and descriptions do the selling on both channels. If you have none yet, start there.
- Work out your real margin after fees, packaging and postage on one product, before you decide where to sell it.
If you want a second opinion on the mix for your own products, book a call and we can talk it through.
Common questions
Is it cheaper to sell on a marketplace or on my own website?
It depends on volume and on who brings the customers. A marketplace has little upfront cost but takes fees on each sale. Your own shop has a build cost and you pay to bring traffic. Compare your margin on one real product under both before deciding.
Do I need my own website if I already sell on eBay or Etsy?
You do not need one to keep selling there, but a website gives you something a marketplace does not: a place you control where people can find your brand, see all your products and buy from you directly.
Can I use both a marketplace and my own shop?
Yes, and many small retailers do. Keep your product information consistent on both, and check each marketplace's policy on directing buyers elsewhere before you do it.
Will people find my own shop without a marketplace?
Not by default. A new shop needs visitors from somewhere: Google searches for your name or products, social media, email, or foot traffic from a physical store. Plan how people will arrive before you launch.
What should I put in my own shop before launch?
Clear product photos, honest descriptions, delivery details, returns information and a contact route. Pages like these are usually enough to start.
Should a brand-new business start on a marketplace?
Often it is a good first step, because it tests demand cheaply. Move your best sellers onto your own shop once you know what sells.
Talk it through, 15 minutes
Book a 15 minute call to talk through a website or online shop for your store.